Compassionate Leave in the UK: Making Fair Decisions in Difficult Cases
Two employees request compassionate leave. One needs to attend a local funeral; the other must travel abroad and help organise arrangements. Giving both the same number of days looks consistent on paper. Whether it meets their needs is another question.
Managers need a common way to assess requests, with room to account for circumstances. First, they must establish which decisions are theirs to make.
Establish rights before exercising discretion
There is no single UK-wide compassionate leave allowance that answers every request. Check the employee’s statutory and contractual entitlements before considering additional discretionary time.
Time off for dependants and parental bereavement leave are distinct provisions, each with its own requirements. Consult current official advice, including GOV.UK’s guidance on time off for dependants and Northern Ireland’s guidance. Establish the right to leave and the payment arrangement separately.
When recording leave in edays absence management software, choose a category that reflects the entitlement or arrangement already established. Identify any additional discretionary time separately so the basis for it remains clear.
Where the policy leaves the position unclear, seek HR advice before approving or refusing the request.
Ask consistent questions about individual needs
For the discretionary part of a request, use the same core questions across the team. What does the employee need time away for? Which dates are fixed? How do travel plans or responsibility for arrangements affect the request? What remains uncertain?
Focus on circumstances rather than how convincingly someone expresses distress. Composure, willingness to share personal details and closeness to a manager are poor grounds for deciding an allowance.
Keep the conversation proportionate. Knowing that someone is organising a funeral may provide enough context; a detailed family history adds little to that decision.
If the employee is unsure how long they will need, agree an initial arrangement and a realistic point for an update. Confirm the dates and payment position already settled, along with anything awaiting clarification.
Work through requests that fall outside the usual pattern
Consider a hypothetical request following the death of a family friend who helped raise the employee. The policy lists certain relatives but leaves other close relationships unaddressed.
That gap calls for assessment, not an automatic refusal. With existing rights established, consider the significance of the relationship, the employee’s responsibilities and the discretion available under the policy. Assess those needs without ranking the loss against a colleague’s bereavement.
Travel creates a different practical issue. Suppose an employee needs extra time because available flights do not align with the funeral date. Distinguish the funeral, necessary travel and any further time requested. Explain which elements the policy covers, where discretion is available and whether another arrangement needs discussion.
Different allowances should be explainable through relevant circumstances. Compare the factors considered in each case, rather than the number of days alone.
Record the reasoning while allowing privacy to be protected
Keep a brief record that another manager could understand. Include the relevant policy provision, the practical reason for an exception, any agreed dates, payment arrangement and review point, while making sure to limit personal information to only what is needed for that purpose.
Explain the decision to the employee, including how to seek a review if something relevant has been overlooked. When declining part of a discretionary request, give a clear reason and discuss alternatives.
Colleagues generally need to know who is unavailable and how work will be covered. Keep the personal circumstances private. A manager can help explain that requests follow a consistent process without discussing why a certain employee received additional time.
Check the consistency across managers
Make sure to review decisions across teams, looking for differences that policy or circumstances often fail to explain. Perhaps one manager routinely authorises extra time while another treats every stated allowance as an absolute ceiling. Similar requests might also receive different payment decisions.
Examine a small selection of appropriately anonymised cases and their recorded reasons. Leave totals alone offer little insight into fairness, and granting less leave is no measure of good management.
Repeated exceptions may reveal unclear or overly narrow policy wording. Improve the guidance where that pattern emerges, so employees have a dependable process rather than having to rely on a particular manager’s goodwill.


